"Advancing Benthic Survey Methods: A Novel Application of Diver-Operated Stereo Video to Survey the Influence of Benthic Habitat Variation on Urchin and Macroalgae Populations in California Rocky Reefs"
A Thesis Defense by Travis Leggett
Live-Stream | May 8th, 2025 at 2:00 pm PDT
Abstract
Subtidal surveys are critical for ecosystem monitoring, traditionally involving diver underwater visual census (UVC), though such methods can impose time or logistical restrictions on the study. Imagery-based techniques, such as diver-operated stereo-video (stereo-DOV), offer precise 3-dimensional measurements from 2-dimensional images, facilitating accurate size and distance estimates as well as the ability to survey large areas quickly. This study compared two stereo-DOV angles (45° and 90°) with UVC to estimate benthic macroinvertebrates, macroalgae, and habitat characteristics (relief, substrate, benthic cover) within kelp forests and urchin barrens. We also explored associations between habitat complexity, measured as relief and substrate transitions. Stereo-DOV and UVC surveys yielded similar estimates for species richness, diversity, and purple sea urchin (Strongylocentrotus purpuratus) densities in urchin barrens, and for stipitate algae species. However, algae significantly reduced the effectiveness of both stereo-DOV angles compared to UVC, largely driven by the absence of cryptic species in stereo surveys. The 90° stereo-DOV surveys performed better in kelp forests relative to 45° surveys but still measured lower species richness and diversity compared to UVC surveys. Habitat characterization accuracy was similar between methods, though these similarities occurred mainly for broad substrate categories (e.g., sand, bedrock) and intermediate relief sizes (>10 cm - <1 m). Habitats with relief transitions (>1 per 10m²) showed marginal positive correlations with giant kelp (Macrocystis pyrifera) and negative correlations with purple urchin densities. Substrate transitions positively correlated with stipitate algae density. Our findings suggest stereo-DOV may be suitable for monitoring community-scale changes in urchin barrens with reduced performance in kelp forests. The 90°Stereo-DOVsurvey estimates were more similar to UVC estimates than 45° stereo-DOV surveys, but habitat was a more significant influence on stereo-DOV performance. This study provides insight into using stereo-DOV as a benthic surveying tool in kelp forests and urchin barrens and the potential for habitat transitions to support kelp populations while limiting urchin movement.
Bio
Travis earned a B.S. in Marine Science from CSUMB after transferring from Santa Monica City College. At CSUMB, Travis was introduced to scientific applications for SCUBA diving and began on a career path that would keep him underwater. During his undergraduate degree, he worked with the Partnership for Interdisciplinary Studies of Coastal Oceans at UCSC with Dr. Mark Carr, where he cemented his passion for subtidal research. He went on to work at Hopkins Marine Station of Stanford University as an independent undergraduate researcher, studying the effects of climate stressors on urchins and other benthic grazers. Travis started his Master's at MLML in 2020 with Dr. James Lindholm, studying the influence of habitat contiguity on urchin populations at Monastery Beach in Carmel Bay. Travis received funding from the Center for Coastal and Marine Ecosystems and the Educational Partnership Program for Minority Serving Institutions through NOAA to expand his research to include a methodological comparison of stereo-video and underwater diver visual surveys. While at MLML, Travis served as the Student Body Treasurer and has certified over 100 individual students for various levels of SCUBA training as an instructor at CSUMB. In his free time, Travis enjoys underwater photography, backpacking, travelling, and spending time with his dog Lehua.


